Simone Joyner
CLEVELAND, Ohio — It’s that time of year again for people to get enraged. That’s because the nominations for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame’s Class of 2020 are due any day now.
But before we get to whether newly eligible acts like Oasis, The Notorious B.I.G. and Weezer will make the cut, or if longtime snubs like Depeche Mode, Doobie Brothers or Kraftwerk will finally get in, let’s take a look back.
Like most Halls of Fame, the Rock Hall can be polarizing. While, you can make an argument for just about any artist that has been inducted, there are a few dozen fans will swear have no business in music’s hallowed ground.
In an effort to upset as many people as possible (Not really, but it’s inevitable), we ranked the 25 worst Rock and Roll Hall of Fame selections of all time. You know, the ones that had you scratching your head wondering why them and not [insert snub here].
This is just one man’s opinion, of course. Just remember: They’re all good, if not great artists. But were they Rock Hall worthy?
Don’t Edit
AP
Don’t Edit
25. Ritchie Valens
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2001
Don’t Edit
Better option: Link Wray
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Associated with “American Pie” (“The Day the Music Died”) after passing away tragically in a plane crash alongside Buddy Holly and The Big Bopper, Valens is a legend. But digging deeper, his Rock Hall resume is pretty light. Yes, he was the pioneer of Chicano rock. And yes, “La Bamba” was a huge hit. But that alone should not have earned him induction when you consider other genre pioneers/one-hit wonders such as Screamin’ Jay Hawkins and Big Mama Thornton have never even been nominated. There were several better options for the Class of 2001 when it comes to 1950s rock and roll pioneers, top among them being Link Wray.
Don’t Edit
Victoria Will
Don’t Edit
24. Darlene Love
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2011
Don’t Edit
Better option: Mary Wells
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
You’d be hard pressed to find a Rock Hall Inductee more lovable than Darlene Love. An essential figure in Phil Spector’s Wall of Sound, Love was (and still is) a great singer. That, along with “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)” are her two main arguments for Rock Hall Induction. But you can’t help but wonder why her and not The Marvelettes or Mary Wells, two essential acts for early Motown with bigger hits to their names.
Don’t Edit
Chris Ware
Don’t Edit
23. The Dave Clark Five
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2008
Don’t Edit
Better option: Lonnie Donegan
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Well, this is sure to upset a lot of baby boomers who still geek out to “Glad All Over.” The Dave Clark Five was a very popular British Invasion act of the 1960s, and the second British act after The Beatles to appear on the “The Ed Sullivan Show.” But The Dave Clark Five’s resume, even compared to just other acts of the 1960s, makes them a borderline Rock Hall candidate. Are they that different from The Crystals, Tommy James & The Shondells, The Shangri-Las or Paul Revere & the Raiders: All acts you could argue for or against? A better choice would have been Lonnie Donegan, the most influential recording artist in British history before The Beatles came around.
Don’t Edit
Getty Images
Don’t Edit
22. Cat Stevens
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2014
Don’t Edit
Better option: Nick Drake
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Cat Stevens had a great run during the first half of the 1970s, with two very essential albums and a string of hits. But you have to wonder how the Rock Hall landed on his name instead of a wide variety of 1970s acts that have never even been nominated, from Doobie Brothers to Emerson, Lake & Palmer to Jim Croce. Even in his own genre, you could make a better case for Nick Drake who, as time goes on, feels like a better choice than Stevens, given how the former’s influence continues to be felt in the artists of today.
Don’t Edit
Keystone Features
Don’t Edit
21. Small Faces/Faces
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2012
Don’t Edit
Better option: New York Dolls
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
It’s easy to see why fans of bands like Mott the Hoople, J. Geils Band or Little Feat might cry foul that their favorite act isn’t in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Small Faces/Faces are. We’re dealing with a combination of two acts here, a la Parliament-Funkadelic (Though, far less significant). The talent and, to a lesser extent, influence are there. Both the Small Faces and, more so, Faces’ back-to-back to basics style and care-free attitude would influence several acts of the 1970s. But in that regard, the impact of, say, the New York Dolls was much greater. After all, Rod Stewart and Ronnie Wood were going to get in anyway.
Don’t Edit
Getty Images
Don’t Edit
20. Donovan
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2012
Don’t Edit
Better option: Phil Ochs
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
A lesser Bob Dylan? Sure. But you could say that about any folk artist really. Donovan’s impact runs deeper, primarily in his merger of folk music with psychedelic pop. But where Donovan falls short is in having just a handful of hits that resonated in the States. That’s not enough to justify his induction over artists who came before such as Phil Ochs or Judy Collins. And how the Nominating Committee saw fit to nominate Donovan years before Joan Baez is beyond me.
Don’t Edit
AP
Don’t Edit
19. The Paul Butterfield Blues Band
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2015
Don’t Edit
Better option: John Mayall’s Bluesbreakers
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Let’s face it. Before being nominated for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame multiple times, most mainstream music fans had never heard of The Paul Butterfield Blues Band. That doesn’t mean the band wasn’t impactful. The Paul Butterfield Blues Band was integral in bringing Chicago blues to white, suburban audiences in the 1960s. But the band’s lack of “Fame” and the fact that an landmark blues artist like Son House shockingly can’t get a nomination makes you question how The Paul Butterfield Blues Band got on the ballot, let alone chosen over Kraftwerk, Nine Inch Nails, Chic and others nominated for the Class of 2015.
Don’t Edit
Hulton Archive/Getty
Don’t Edit
18. Electric Light Orchestra
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2017
Don’t Edit
Better option: Jethro Tull
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
When you take into account Jeff Lynne’s production legacy, then you can make a solid case for Electric Light Orchestra’s Rock Hall worthiness. But the band on its own — I’m just not seeing it. ELO got in as part of the Nominating Committee’s surge in recent years to include B (or maybe even C) level classic-rock acts. But nothing really puts Electric Light Orchestra ahead of other 1970s acts s like The Guess Who, Bad Company or Bachman-Turner Overdrive. Then again, I wouldn’t induct those bands either.
Don’t Edit
AP/Los Angeles Times
Don’t Edit
17. Laura Nyro
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2012
Don’t Edit
Better option: Judy Collins
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Laura Nyro is one of the first names that comes up when people list the least deserving members of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. And it’s easy to see why. It feels like her nomination was plucked out of thin air. That doesn’t mean she wasn’t a great artist. Nyro most certainly was. But she feels somewhat fringe compared to almost any other inductee. She’s sort of like a lesser Randy Newman, where as the Rock Hall could have opted for someone with more influence like the aforementioned Judy Collins.
Don’t Edit
Getty Images
Don’t Edit
16. Frankie Lymon & the Teenagers
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 1993
Don’t Edit
Better option: Billy Ward and His Dominoes
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Frankie Lymon and the Teenagers were nominated for the Rock Hall every year since the beginning until they were inducted in 1993. Why did the Nominating Committee have the group on par with the greatest rock and roll acts of all time. Sure, Lymon has a compelling story as a child star who died young. But while the lack of noteworthy catalog has kept other influential 1950s acts out of the Rock Hall, namely Johnny Ace and Jesse Belvin, it didn’t affect Lymon. Maybe in the “Early Influences” category this makes sense. Otherwise, can most people name anything besides “Why Do Fools Fall In Love?”
Don’t Edit
Stephen Lovekin
Don’t Edit
15. Little Anthony and the Imperials
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2009
Don’t Edit
Better option: Ben E. King (solo)
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Little Anthony and the Imperials’ longevity is impressive. Of all the acts come out of doo-wop and move into R&B, few, if any, had a longer run. But the significance of that run is debatable, especially when you start rifling off the list of influential R&B artists that aren’t in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame: Joe Tex, Mary Wells, Junior Walker & the All Stars, Ben E. King (solo), The Crystals, etc.
Don’t Edit
George Konig
Don’t Edit
14. Del Shannon
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 1999
Don’t Edit
Better option: Chubby Checker
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
It must have been easy to get behind the idea of Del Shannon being in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame when artists like Tom Petty and Jeff Lynne practically worshiped the ground he walked on. But Shannon is one of those artists whose legacy is really built around just one song in “Runaway.” Yes, it was a No. 1 hit and Shannon had a distinct style. But why him and not someone like Chubby Checker or Tommy James & The Shondells.
Don’t Edit
Getty Images
Don’t Edit
13. Bobby Darin
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 1990
Don’t Edit
Better option: Screamin’ Jay Hawkins
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Looking at the list of successful artists of the 1950s, Bobby Darin certainly has some of the deccade’s biggest hits, including “Splish, Splash” and “Mack the Knife.” But how much those songs resonated in the decades that followed? Darin was a famous star who became an actor. But musically, it would have benefitted the Rock Hall to have pushed for an artist with a more unique style and sound.
Don’t Edit
Ian Showell
Don’t Edit
12. Chicago
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2016
Don’t Edit
Better option: Procol Harum
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Saying Chicago was a successful band during the 1970s would be an understatement. But even after selling all those records, they never really felt like a larger than life act. And when they came close, they morphed into a lame soft rock act with songs like “You’re the Inspiration” and “Hard to Say I’m Sorry.” Yes, Chicago brought horns into rock in the 1970s. But they weren’t the first or, arguably, the best at it, considering the Mothers of Invention and Electric Flag haven’t been nominated.
Don’t Edit
Plain Dealer Historical Archive
Don’t Edit
11. The Lovin’ Spoonful
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2000
Don’t Edit
Better option: The Shangri-Las
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
I’m okay with kicking The Lovin’ Spoonful out of the Rock Hall based on the band’s Induction Ceremony performance alone. Yes, the band had some hits during the 1960s. But they weren’t a game-changer the level of peers like Grateful Dead or The Mamas and the Papas. And in terms of the 1960s as a whole, you have to imagine the impact of act like Joe Tex or The Shangri-Las stretches much further. Heck, I’d take The Monkees over these guys all day, everyday.
Don’t Edit
Robert Cianflone
Don’t Edit
10. Bon Jovi
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2018
Don’t Edit
Better option: Iron Maiden
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
If we’re talking just commercial appeal, record sales and longevity, by all means Bon Jovi belongs in the Rock Hall. Influence and authenticity? Not so much. I could get behind the band’s induction more had Desmond Child been included, since there’s something to be said for the songwriting on choruses to songs like “Livin’ on a Prayer.” As it stands, however, I don’t see any significant changes to the history of rock music if Bon Jovi never existed, other than the Goo Goo Dolls never becoming a band or there being fewer songs to sing along to at weddings. Why Bon Jovi and not Boston, Thin Lizzy or Bad Company?
Don’t Edit
AP
Don’t Edit
9. Journey
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2017
Don’t Edit
Better option: Duran Duran
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
The arguments for and against Journey and Bon Jovi are the same. Only, Journey fans are even more passionate, and, thus, more likely to slash the tires on my car. Yes, “Don’t Stop Believin'” is an indelible pop song. But you know who else made at least one indelible pop song? Duran Duran, Whitney Houston, the Go-Go’s and INXS, each not in the Rock Hall despite having more influence on today’s music landscape than Journey. Whose getting in next: Nickelback?
Don’t Edit
M. McKeown
Don’t Edit
8. Gene Pitney
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2002
Don’t Edit
Better option: Harry Nilsson
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
There’s a case to be made for Pitney in a specialty category, considering his work as a sound engineer and songwriter on hits like “He’s a Rebel” and “Hello, Mary Lou.” But as a “Performer” it doesn’t make much sense. His impact during the 1960s doesn’t measure up to other acts that aren’t in the Rock Hall like Love, Dick Dale or Jack and Dean.
Don’t Edit
Getty Images
Don’t Edit
7. The Moody Blues
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2018
Don’t Edit
Better option: King Crimson
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
The Moody Blues made good (if not boring) music, some of it great. But this an example of the Nominating Committee and its Boomer voters preferring a second- or third-tier classic rock act rather than a top-tier band from a later decade. The Moody Blues certainly weren’t the kind of groundbreaking act snubs like T. Rex, The Jam or Kraftwerk were.
Don’t Edit
Plain Dealer Historical Archives
Don’t Edit
6. Bill Withers
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2015
Don’t Edit
Better option: Lionel Richie and the Commodores
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Bill Withers is a fine R&B act with a handful of great soul songs. But even within his own genre, maybe (MAYBE) he rates as one of the 100 most important R&B acts of all time and certainly isn’t in the top 50. The Nominating Committee seemingly pulled Withers’ name out of thin air and voters went for it, despite there being several better options in the forms of Chic, Luther Vandross, Kool & the Gang, Barry White, Rick James, The Commodores and The Ohio Players. I could go on.
Don’t Edit
Getty Images
Don’t Edit
5. Jeff Beck
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2009
Don’t Edit
Better option: Dick Dale
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
If prior to 2009, Jeff Beck felt like a Rock and Roll Hall of Famer, it’s because he was as a member of the Yardbirds, and rightfully so. But there was no reason for him to become a two-time inductee, other than the Rock Hall wanting to put together a guitar showcase at its annual ceremony. Beck is undoubtedly one of the greatest guitarists of all time. But his solo career leaves something to be desired in terms of significance.
Don’t Edit
Promotional Handout
Don’t Edit
4. The Dells
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2004
Don’t Edit
Better option: Teddy Pendergrass
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
If you find something significant that separates The Dells from a large group of other like-minded R&B/doo-wop acts from the same period, please let me know what it is. The Dells have one (“Oh What a Nite”), maybe two (“Stay In My Corner”) essential hits, which somehow got them into the Rock Hall ahead of The Dramatics, The Stylistics, Harold Melvin, Teddy Pendergrass, The Dramatics, The Spinners, The Del Vikings and The Chi-Lites, among others.
Don’t Edit
Ethan Miller
Don’t Edit
3. Joan Jett and the Blackhearts
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2015
Don’t Edit
Better option: The Runaways
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
This concept of Joan Jett as the archetype of the female rock star is a bit weird. Yes, when you think of a woman with a guitar, she comes to mind. But she did not invent that or do anything with it that hadn’t been done before. In fact, her two biggest hits are cover songs. The fact that Joan Jett & the Blackhearts are in the Rock Hall and The Shangri-Las aren’t is a bit absurd. That’s not say Jett doesn’t belong in the museum. She’s just in there with the wrong group. The Runaways were far more essential.
Don’t Edit
Timothy A. Clark
Don’t Edit
2. Percy Sledge
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2005
Don’t Edit
Better option: Joe Tex
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
There’s a thought among some people that a push for Percy Sledge to get into the Rock Hall was made after he performed at Steve Van Zandt’s wedding. I’m going to ignore that, only because, if true (which it may very well be), it’s INSANE! Sledge has one hit. That’s not discredit his other work. That’s just a fact. “When a Man Loves a Woman” is all anyone knows. Does that make him influential? Sledge was an important artist in terms of southern soul in the 1960s or, better yet, “When a Man Loves a Woman” was an important song, one of the essential hits of the decade. But, in terms of body of work, there just isn’t much else there.
Don’t Edit
Hulton Archive/Getty Images
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
Inducted: 2019
Don’t Edit
Better option: Tina Turner
Don’t Edit
Don’t Edit
If the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame were to admit Stevie Nicks was nominated because she finished first in the “Voice Your Choice” in-museum fan vote, I’d let this go. However, the Rock Hall Foundation has said the vote had no influence on the committee. So we’re left to wonder why Nicks was worthy of becoming the first two-time female inductee. To say Nicks has more than one essential album or song would be a reach. And while she’s an influential figure, most of that (if not all of it) can be chalked up to her time with Fleetwood Mac. The list of women who have had better solo careers than Nicks is too long to list here. So, I’ll just list the women who would have made better two-time inductees, which includes Tina Turner, Diana Ross and Grace Slick.
Don’t Edit